• Take a medium-sized mixing bowl that is washed and cleaned.
• In this bowl, add the cornstarch and then pour a little water into it. Stir both of them and make a slurry having a smooth texture.
• Bring a non-stick saucepan and pour the water and cornstarch mixture into it.
• Keep the flame medium and heat up the mixture. While cooking, continue stirring for some time and then you have to add the other dressing ingredients.
• Firstly add the celery seeds and then you must stir the onion powder into this mixture. You must give a good stir to your mixture at this point.
• Then add some water and pour the apple cider vinegar into it.
• Sprinkle some salt and pepper into the mixture and then stir in the butter. In the end stir the sugar, into the cooking sauce.
• Stir well.
• Simmer for some time and once you acquired the required texture of the dressing, you must turn off the heat and let the mixture air cool.
• Use in recipes or serve as a dip after refrigeration.

For Catalina Colonial

• You must add the ketchup to the mixture and also add the sweet pickle relish to prepare this version of the dressing.

For Creamy Colonial Dressing

• The addition of a tablespoon of mustard, a tablespoon of dried oregano leaves, and a tablespoon of corn syrup along with the garlic powder and mayonnaise. Pour some mayonnaise and the creamy colonial dressing is ready.